Ok, now we've calmed down a bit, I was, and still am, of the opinion Goodwin was/is limited as a manager.
He had a very up and down season with us the season he left, Aberdeen took him on the crest (didn't he have a horrendous run earlier that season?)but I was on record saying they had jumped the gun and he was, IMO, average.
Too defensively minded, a draw and parking the bus against the OF was his idea of fun.
Saying he was our best manager in a generation, purely on league finish is selective and omitting cup victories which should be taken into account so, no , I don't accept that.
As I mentioned earlier, there was growing criticism form the Dundee United support which has slightly abated after the win against Raith.
Let's see how he does next season in the top league.