Jump to content

Speculation Thread


jimdickloyal

Recommended Posts


Rick - it's not new. There's a wee lad I recommended to St Mirren through the official website 6 years ago who today scored a double as part of the Motherwell side that sunk St Mirren under 15's 6-3 at Ralston. Another lad that I recommended to St Mirren got a trial with the club just over two years ago. Apparently he wasn't better than anything the club had at the time - which is fine - but this week I'm told he's signing professional terms with Dunfermline at the age of 15 and Manchester City are extremely keen on signing him. There was another Wishaw Wycombe lad that I ranted and raved about on the official website several years ago whilst the likes of Captain Sensible scoffed. Lewis Kidd went on to captain Scotland at Under 16's level and has been on the Celtic bench a number of times last season. I also tipped his little brother for success and he's getting rave reports in the Under 15 squad as well.

I can go back further and point out that I sent e-mails to the club which were ignored recommended a very young Mark Reynolds for scouting whilst he was playing for his school team - although I've since been told he was never going anywhere other than Motherwell and there have been a number of others - one of which St Mirren DID actually sign

I did also contemplate contacting St Mirren about Stephen O'Donnell when I knew he was being released from Celtic. He's another ex Wishaw Wycombe player and I knew his Dad really well with him being Chairman of our club back then. I rated him pretty highly, but with St Mirren having already had a look at four of our players and deciding not to take it further I left it. Since then he's done very well indeed at Partick Thistle.

'Course it's not like I'm some kind of super scout. I'm just someone - amongst thousands of others - who watches football at different levels of the game on a regular basis and who knows where some of the good kids are. A sensible club would tap into those kinds of networks but some clubs.......I'll let you fill in the blanks.

Did it occur to you that St Mirren may well have followed up on your suggestions only to be knocked back by the players in question?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Did it occur to you that St Mirren may well have followed up on your suggestions only to be knocked back by the players in question?

Yep - but they didn't. The closest to that situation we ever got was David Longwell inviting four lads along to Ralston for trials - as I said in my post. One lad had one session before being told he wasn't good enough, two lasted maybe three months and the fourth stayed till the summer break without either being signed or being told whether he was to return for the following session. The lad at Dunfermline was one of the two that were turned away after three months. He would have signed for St Mirren had they been interested because the trip to Ralston was much more convenient for his family than the trip to Kinross. The Kidds were never approached, neither was Mark Reynolds.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest somner9

You know, after two lines ,all i read is Blah ,Blah, Blah !

"Two Lines"?

I'd have thought one would require at least four lines of nose candy to counter-act the Dicko effect!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yep - but they didn't. The closest to that situation we ever got was David Longwell inviting four lads along to Ralston for trials - as I said in my post. One lad had one session before being told he wasn't good enough, two lasted maybe three months and the fourth stayed till the summer break without either being signed or being told whether he was to return for the following session. The lad at Dunfermline was one of the two that were turned away after three months. He would have signed for St Mirren had they been interested because the trip to Ralston was much more convenient for his family than the trip to Kinross. The Kidds were never approached, neither was Mark Reynolds.

So you're their friend coach AND agent

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Rick - it's not new. There's a wee lad I recommended to St Mirren through the official

website 6 years ago who today scored a double as part of the Motherwell side that sunk St Mirren under 15's 6-3 at Ralston. Another lad that I recommended to St Mirren got a trial with the club just over two years ago. Apparently he wasn't better than anything the club had at the time - which is fine - but this week I'm told he's signing professional terms with Dunfermline at the age of 15 and Manchester City are extremely keen on signing him. There was another Wishaw Wycombe lad that I ranted and raved about on the official website several years ago whilst the likes of Captain Sensible scoffed. Lewis Kidd went on to captain Scotland at Under 16's level and has been on the Celtic bench a number of times last season. I also tipped his little brother for success and he's getting rave reports in the Under 15 squad as well.

I can go back further and point out that I sent e-mails to the club which were ignored recommended a very young Mark Reynolds for scouting whilst he was playing for his school team - although I've since been told he was never going anywhere other than Motherwell and there have been a number of others - one of which St Mirren DID actually sign

I did also contemplate contacting St Mirren about Stephen O'Donnell when I knew he was being released from Celtic. He's another ex Wishaw Wycombe player and I knew his Dad really well with him being Chairman of our club back then. I rated him pretty highly, but with St Mirren having already had a look at four of our players and deciding not to take it further I left it. Since then he's done very well indeed at Partick Thistle.

'Course it's not like I'm some kind of super scout. I'm just someone - amongst thousands of others - who watches football at different levels of the game on a regular basis and who knows where some of the good kids are. A sensible club would tap into those kinds of networks but some clubs.......I'll let you fill in the blanks.

i know for a fact u r lying...every name given in is followed up...how do i know? cause i followed them up.....hundreds of names are given in and are followed up...most r bound to not be as good as we have....it is very hard to judge how an 11year old will be at 16...
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I personally recommended a young Portuguese I saw playing football on the beach while on holiday in the Algarve in '95. Needless to say the club never took any notice of me, and that youngster became the most expensive footballer in history.

When will the club start listening to random anoraks before they plan their transfer policy?

whistling.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest somner9

I personally recommended a young Portuguese I saw playing football on the beach while on holiday in the Algarve in '95. Needless to say the club never took any notice of me, and that youngster became the most expensive footballer in history.

When will the club start listening to random anoraks before they plan their transfer policy?

whistling.gif

Maybe if the moaning git was a supporter, shareholder and GAVE to the club and local community they'd listen to his drivel occasionaly?

he must be like the kiss of death to those young boys hopes when he gets going

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Maybe if the moaning git was a supporter, shareholder and GAVE to the club and local community they'd listen to his drivel occasionaly?

he must be like the kiss of death to those young boys hopes when he gets going

its fannies like him running clubs...no got a fecking clue what they are doing and then people ask why Scottish football is a mess...get these clowns out...
Link to comment
Share on other sites

i know for a fact u r lying...every name given in is followed up...how do i know? cause i followed them up.....hundreds of names are given in and are followed up...most r bound to not be as good as we have....it is very hard to judge how an 11year old will be at 16...

Having just read your exploits on another thread about ' incestuous three ways, and your pathological hatred of cheesy, I hope to god you have no part in the selection process of pro-youth players for any team.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I personally recommended a young Portuguese I saw playing football on the beach while on holiday in the Algarve in '95. Needless to say the club never took any notice of me, and that youngster became the most expensive footballer in history.

 

When will the club start listening to random anoraks before they plan their transfer policy?

 

Posted Image

are you Alex Miller in disguise?
Link to comment
Share on other sites

There is a whole load of fishing going on over on Twitterland. A lot of people in the "know" but not willing to share. Pm's n Dm's can be used to share even if you don't want it published.

I think its all an elaborate wind up with a number of the #mirrenmafia in on it. I posted the Higdon rumour after one of them letting the name slip, plus a random Well fan who fell for the Well Fans Twitter joke.

I'll be delighted if I'm wrong.

Sent from my HTC Sensation Z710e using Black & White Army mobile app

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think its all an elaborate wind up with a number of the #mirrenmafia in on it. I posted the Higdon rumour after one of them letting the name slip, plus a random Well fan who fell for the Well Fans Twitter joke.

I'll be delighted if I'm wrong.

Sent from my HTC Sensation Z710e using Black & White Army mobile app

yeah that's what I'm thinking. Only worse thing than useless speculation is useless "fishing". No suitable hand sign smileys available.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

i know for a fact u r lying...every name given in is followed up...how do i know? cause i followed them up.....hundreds of names are given in and are followed up...most r bound to not be as good as we have....it is very hard to judge how an 11year old will be at 16...

Read my post again. The ONLY lad I claim wasn't followed up on was Mark Reynolds. I know for a fact I'm right on that one. I look forward to your apology

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Maybe if the moaning git was a supporter, shareholder and GAVE to the club and local community they'd listen to his drivel occasionaly?

 

he must be like the kiss of death to those young boys hopes when he gets going

Aye it must be. One is a transfer target for Man City, one was Scotland Under 16 captain, one was Motherwell captain, one had a great season at Partick, and two more are hotly tipped at Motherwell and Celtic. :rolleyes:

Sent from my GT-I9100 using Black & White Army mobile app

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...