Jump to content

jimdickloyal

Speculation Thread

Recommended Posts


7 hours ago, Slartibartfast said:
12 hours ago, jaybee said:
If you insist.  OK (Oran Kearney) ? (question mark) OK no sh*t (Oran Kearney is not shit)   with me so far?, next bit........... Lyons OK 2 (Brad Lyons is OK also)  I'm sure you can work out the rest ........really not difficult.  emoji41.png   Oh and by the way ........................... get a haircut.
by the way this was targeted at Lucy not you good self.  emoji41.png

I sed Y, no wot. emoji14.png

OOOOrps! but hey took me blooming ages to type all that gobledegook out don't spoil it.  I suppose the answer should be Y not?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Yep and Steve Clarke (who has vast experience at a very high level by the way) has been rewarded by moving into a more senior job. Do you think I’m suggesting OK has done better than Clarke? default_blink.png

also feel free to point out where I said OK got 100% of players performing well at the club? Quite lofty expectations don’t you think? He did enough for us to survive and complete the last quarter of fixtures as one of the most in form teams in the league. A near miracle given the mess he inherited imo  

You always come back to the Liam Smith point which is very strange considering how easily it was to defend my comment... United not building an SP able side no? default_rolleyes.gif

Nine games including failing to beat amateur/ non league players.

We know you’re a troll but even this effort from you is very poor. 

 

How have you defended the Liam Smith point?

 

He’s signed for a Championship side at the start of the transfer window. It means the point you were making last year about the only reason that a Premiership club didn’t sign him cos it was late on in the window was wrong!

 

You are right on one point. United aren’t building an SPL capable side.... how could they be! They’re in the Championship!

 

They’re building a side they think is capable of getting promoted within their championship budget.

 

An entirely different matter!

 

If they were building an SPL side then they wouldn’t have signed Cammy Smith!

 

It’s not a matter of opinion that can be defended. It’s just a plain fact that you were wrong. Yet again!

 

As for the 9 games, if you’re including the cup games then the fact is that he qualified from the group stage.... unlike Jack Ross the previous season!

 

You’re the King of Wrong!

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
19 minutes ago, Wendy Saintss said:

 


How have you defended the Liam Smith point?

He’s signed for a Championship side at the start of the transfer window. It means the point you were making last year about the only reason that a Premiership club didn’t sign him cos it was late on in the window was wrong!

It’s not a matter of opinion that can be defended. It’s just a plain fact that you were wrong. Yet again!

As for the 9 games, if you’re including the cup games then the fact is that he qualified from the group stage.... unlike Jack Ross the previous season!

You’re the King of Wrong!

 

So I wasn’t wrong the point was an expression of my opinion. And it was that Liam Smith could have been a good signing & we might very well have went for him had he come available earlier in the window. Given that he had another great season & has been signed by a club with SP ambitions that have signed several players from the SP, I think that’s a justifiable point...

can you see how his early availability equalled him getting signed by a club wanting to build an SP squad could support that? (You’re also wrong that they aren’t building a squad capable of being SP quality unless you think they intent to sign 11 new starting players if they get promoted  :rolleyes:

Jack Ross didn’t fail to beat an amateur & a non league side which is what I’m basing part of the reason for sacking him on. You saying about the league cup qualification which I didn’t mention is irrelevant, so again not wrong. Trying to twist words to fit your agenda is very cute but it just shows you as the troll we all know you are. 

You didn’t think we should have sacked Stubbs & taken on OK. We did and he guided us to SP survival so people with that view like yourself (an extreme minority) seem to be the ones that are wrong... unless you’d rather we tried our luck keeping NBM, King, Kpekawa, Heaton and the likes? :lol:

Edited by bazil85

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, bazil85 said:

So I wasn’t wrong the point was an expression of my opinion. And it was that Liam Smith could have been a good signing & we might very well have went for him had he come available earlier in the window. Given that he had another great season & has been signed by a club with SP ambitions that have signed several players from the SP, I think that’s a justifiable point...

can you see how his early availability equalled him getting signed by a club wanting to build an SP squad could support that? :rolleyes:

Jack Ross didn’t fail to beat an amateur & a non league side which is what I’m basing part of the reason for sacking him on. You saying about the league cup qualification which I didn’t mention is irrelevant, so again not wrong. Trying to twist words to fit your agenda is very cute but it just shows you as the troll we all know you are. 

You didn’t think we should have sacked Stubbs & taken on OK. We did and he guided us to SP survival so people with that view like yourself (an extreme minority) seem to be the ones that are wrong... unless you’d rather we tried our luck keeping NBM, King, Kpekawa, Heaton and the likes? :lol:

IF Liam Smith was good enough for the Premiership how come he played last season in the Championship and is there again next season...?

Does anyone seriously think Liam Smith is better than Paul McGinn ?

Don't waste your time on the troll - he is fishing for bites - ignore him and the forum is much better...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, Sweeper07 said:

IF Liam Smith was good enough for the Premiership how come he played last season in the Championship and is there again next season...?

Does anyone seriously think Liam Smith is better than Paul McGinn ?

Don't waste your time on the troll - he is fishing for bites - ignore him and the forum is much better...

My point was that Liam Smith didn’t become available until very late last summer after a lot of teams had already finalised much of their squad. I was purely speculating that if he had been available since day 1 we might have went for him. Wendy Saintss has been really upset over this speculation for close to a year now and can’t let it go. 

Paul McGinn had a great season, delighted with him. hindsight is a wonderful thing & there’s nothing to say he would have been the clear choice if both were available at the same time. McGinn is also able to play one up so it wouldn’t have necessarily had to be a choice. 

As for this season, I’d be surprised if United aren’t able to compete financially with some smaller SP teams & will have a draw for players due to their size & inevitability that they’ll eventually be back. 

It was all speculation, never statement of fact. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites



Says the internet gangsta who can’t even read dates!

Still waiting for you to put me in hospital!

Gotta love cowardly cockless for arranging fights he doesn’t turn up for and threatening folk on the internet!

What a fud!
You'll be able to provide proof of the allegation that I was going to put you in hospital, threatening folk and arranging fights.

No, didn't think so. That's #thichasfcuk living up to his hashtag. 🤪

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

People are overly harsh on Heaton, very few people would turn down a higher wage and the chance to play at a higher level.

Not his fault the board sanctioned the fee for him either.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
18 minutes ago, gc_SMFC said:

People are overly harsh on Heaton, very few people would turn down a higher wage and the chance to play at a higher level.

Not his fault the board sanctioned the fee for him either.

I was of this opinion too but he's hardly conducted himself very professionally in his time here. 

Time to cut him loose and move on. A very expensive mistake to make and we were taken in by the appraisal of a complete shyster.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
17 minutes ago, gc_SMFC said:

People are overly harsh on Heaton, very few people would turn down a higher wage and the chance to play at a higher level.

Not his fault the board sanctioned the fee for him either.

While the Club that pays his wages and gave him his big chance were playing in the playoffs for their future in the Premiership,  Heaton flew off on holiday. Most players with a Twitter account mention their Club now and then. Not the bold Josh. My impression is he does not give a f**k about St Mirren.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
11 minutes ago, Sonny said:

While the Club that pays his wages and gave him his big chance were playing in the playoffs for their future in the Premiership,  Heaton flew off on holiday. Most players with a Twitter account mention their Club now and then. Not the bold Josh. My impression is he does not give a f**k about St Mirren.

He's possibly read, or been told, the consistent abuse he gets on here? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
12 minutes ago, Sonny said:

While the Club that pays his wages and gave him his big chance were playing in the playoffs for their future in the Premiership,  Heaton flew off on holiday. Most players with a Twitter account mention their Club now and then. Not the bold Josh. My impression is he does not give a f**k about St Mirren.

Interesting to compare Josh Heaton with Cody Cooke . It's all about attitude .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
28 minutes ago, MenstrieSaint said:

Interesting to compare Josh Heaton with Cody Cooke . It's all about attitude .

And ability. I have a wonderful attitude but I am told that I am a complete haddie.

Edited by magnus

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Interesting to compare Josh Heaton with Cody Cooke . It's all about attitude .
Attitude & Ability...

When Heaton was dropped and ended up training with the reserves, he took the huff and ended up getting shipped out on loan.

Cooke on the other hand could have done the exact same but he got his head down, worked hard and proved many people (especially on here) wrong.

Looking forward to seeing him develop more next season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...