Jump to content

Punt Or Keep?


Recommended Posts

If you were in charge, on current form, who would you want to punt / keep at the end of the season?


Jamie Langfield

Daniel Wilks


Jason Naismith

Sean Kelly

Andy Webster

Jack Baird

Keith Watson

Jordan Stewart

Gary Irvine


Jim Goodwin

Alan Gow

Stuart Carswell

Cameron Howieson

Stephen Mallan

Scott Agnew

Lewis Morgan

Lewis McLear

Barry Cuddihy

Alex Cooper

Kyle McAllister

Rocco Quinn


Cal Gallagher

David Clarkson

Lawrence Shankland

Stevey Thompson

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Jamie Langfield - keep

Daniel Wilks - keep


Jason Naismith - keep

Sean Kelly - punt

Andy Webster - keep

Jack Baird - keep

Keith Watson - keep

Jordan Stewart - keep

Gary Irvine - keep


Jim Goodwin - punt (he will be gone anyway)

Alan Gow - punt

Stuart Carswell - punt

Cameron Howieson - punt

Stephen Mallan - keep

Scott Agnew - punt

Lewis Morgan - keep

Lewis McLear - keep

Barry Cuddihy - punt

Alex Cooper - keep

Kyle McAllister - keep

Rocco Quinn - keep


Cal Gallagher - punt

David Clarkson - keep

Lawrence Shankland - keep

Stevey Thompson - punt (too old now sadly)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jamie Langfield - keep

Daniel Wilks - keep

Jason Naismith - keep

Sean Kelly - punt

Andy Webster - keep

Jack Baird - keep

Keith Watson - keep

Jordan Stewart - keep

Gary Irvine - keep

Jim Goodwin - punt (he will be gone anyway)

Alan Gow - punt

Stuart Carswell - punt

Cameron Howieson - punt

Stephen Mallan - keep

Scott Agnew - punt

Lewis Morgan - keep

Lewis McLear - keep

Barry Cuddihy - punt

Alex Cooper - keep

Kyle McAllister - keep

Rocco Quinn - keep

Cal Gallagher - punt

David Clarkson - keep

Lawrence Shankland - keep

Stevey Thompson - punt (too old now sadly)

You going for 'blank canvas' next season ? :P

Link to comment
Share on other sites

From what I've seen this season and especially last night:

Jamie Langfield - Keep (just - not that impressed overall, but needs a good back-up to challenge)
Daniel Wilks - Probably Keep but I haven't seen too much of him in action
Jason Naismith - Keep
Sean Kelly - Keep
Andy Webster - Not sure, pretty unimpressive last night - maybe told to punt it upfield, apperaed to have little or no composure, probably a Keep
Jack Baird - Keep, Just as he's young and has much to learn - lost confidence last night
Keith Watson - Keep
Jordan Stewart - Keep
Gary Irvine - Keep
Jim Goodwin - Like to keep, but will probably go
Alan Gow - Punt
Stuart Carswell - Punt
Cameron Howieson - Probably will go - he's one of these players that I think if given more of a run could have been successful
Stephen Mallan - Keep
Scott Agnew - Punt just an no more - has good points but too inconsistent
Lewis Morgan - Probably keep
Lewis McLear - Probably keep
Barry Cuddihy - Punt
Alex Cooper - On last night's perfomance he couldn't beat a carpet never mind his opposite number - punt
Kyle McAllister - keep
Rocco Quinn - Unsure
Cal Gallagher - Keep
David Clarkson - Keep
Lawrence Shankland - Keep
Stevey Thompson - Sadly Punt
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not a question to really worry about. Most of the squad are out of contract, as I said elsewhere Mallan may get picked up, likewise McCallister. Galling as it is if Agnew is on a 2 year deal no one will want him and we will be stuck with him whilst out of petulance or whatever drives his decision making our manager will ensure Goodwin is gone.

Expect to see Goody back playing for the opposition next season and giving Rae it up his ronson lighter. Most of the squad will simply go and we will have become like Dumbarton... A struggling championship club.

Wouldnt be surprised if tne U20's get hooked for next season too. Rae doesn't see the point in them.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not a question to really worry about. Most of the squad are out of contract, as I said elsewhere Mallan may get picked up, likewise McCallister. Galling as it is if Agnew is on a 2 year deal no one will want him and we will be stuck with him whilst out of petulance or whatever drives his decision making our manager will ensure Goodwin is gone.

Expect to see Goody back playing for the opposition next season and giving Rae it up his ronson lighter. Most of the squad will simply go and we will have become like Dumbarton... A struggling championship club.

Wouldnt be surprised if tne U20's get hooked for next season too. Rae doesn't see the point in them.

Or we could play to our strengths, build on our defence. Add a couple of players to our midfield - find a strike partner for Clarkson and make a genuine push for promotion.

Development squad are amongst the best in Scotland, and one of the few facilities with 5 star status. We've also recently announced plans for a new multi-million £ training facility. Not a chance we'll get rid of the U20's, regardless of what Rae thinks.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you were in charge, on current form, who would you want to punt / keep at the end of the season?
Jamie Langfield probably keep
Daniel Wilks keep
Jason Naismith keep
Sean Kelly keep
Andy Webster punt
Jack Baird keep
Keith Watson keep
Jordan Stewart keep
Gary Irvine punt
Jim Goodwin keep but obviously will go
Alan Gow punt
Stuart Carswell punt
Cameron Howieson punt
Stephen Mallan keep
Scott Agnew punt
Lewis Morgan keep
Lewis McLear keep
Barry Cuddihy punt
Alex Cooper punt
Kyle McAllister keep
Rocco Quinn keep
Cal Gallagher punt
David Clarkson punt
Lawrence Shankland keep
Stevey Thompson punt

For me punt more than half the midfielders although most that are left are very young to play consistently so at least another 3/4 decent midfielders required.

Shankland will go elsewhere so a whole new forward line for me.

A decent experienced centre back who still has legs to play alongside Watson. With Naismith back we do not need Irvine (who hasn't particularly impressed me).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you were in charge, on current form, who would you want to punt / keep at the end of the season?
Jamie Langfield Expensive and unfocussed-Punt
Daniel Wilks Dunno
Jason Naismith keep
Sean Kelly Keep
Andy Webster Punt now
Jack Baird Keep
Keith Watson Keep
Jordan Stewart Undecided
Gary Irvine Punt
Jim Goodwin Punt-not for the first time, a manager has issues with this man
Alan Gow Keep till Christmas If Gow never has more than 3 months on his contract then he might perform
Stuart Carswell punt
Cameron Howieson Punt
Stephen Mallan Keep, but sell if the price is right
Scott Agnew Keep
Lewis Morgan keep
Lewis McLear Keep
Barry Cuddihy Punt
Alex Cooper Punt
Kyle McAllister Keep till christmas
Rocco Quinn Punt
Cal Gallagher Punt
David Clarkson Keep him if we can
Lawrence Shankland Needs to be at another club
Stevey Thompson Punt, albeit 2 years too late

We are going to be left with around 15-18 places to fill in a 26 person squad, so there is no issue with keeping the Ralston graduates on for a year. For me, I'd like to see maybe 4 or 5 signings of superior class and the rest being made up of journeymen and improving youngsters. The league will be tight yet again next year and it would take major investment to even contend for the top spot, Several teams have proven that you only need to be able to score to get a run going in this division and we should be focussing on 2 front men, a pacy attacking creative mid and maybe one really good centre back.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jamie Langfield - Keep as GK Coach and reserve keeper

Daniel Wilks - No idea


Jason Naismith - Keep

Sean Kelly - Punt

Andy Webster - Punt

Jack Baird - Punt

Keith Watson - Keep

Jordan Stewart - Punt

Gary Irvine - Keep


Jim Goodwin - Punt

Alan Gow - Punt

Stuart Carswell - Punt

Cameron Howieson - Punt

Stephen Mallan - Keep

Scott Agnew - Punt

Lewis Morgan - Keep

Lewis McLear - Keep

Barry Cuddihy - Keep

Alex Cooper - Punt

Kyle McAllister - Keep

Rocco Quinn - Undecided


Cal Gallagher - Punt

David Clarkson - Punt

Lawrence Shankland - Keep

Stevey Thompson - Punt



It's time for a fresh start.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jamie Langfield - keep as u 20 coach

Daniel Wilks - keep


Jason Naismith - keep

Sean Kelly - punt

Andy Webster - punt

Jack Baird - punt

Keith Watson - has to stay been superb since rae come in

Jordan Stewart - keep

Gary Irvine - keep


Jim Goodwin - has to stay build team around him

Alan Gow - punt

Stuart Carswell - punt

Cameron Howieson - punt

Stephen Mallan - keep

Scott Agnew - punt

Lewis Morgan - keep

Lewis McLear - keep

Barry Cuddihy - punt

Alex Cooper - keep

Kyle McAllister - keep

Rocco Quinn - keep


Cal Gallagher - punt

David Clarkson - keep but think hell be away elsewhere

Lawrence Shankland - keep but think hell be away elsewhere

Stevey Thompson - sad was its went for the big man
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jamie Langfield - keep

Daniel Wilks - keep


Jason Naismith - punt

Sean Kelly - punt

Andy Webster - punt

Jack Baird - punt

Keith Watson - keep (but he'll get a better gig)

Jordan Stewart - punt

Gary Irvine - punt


Jim Goodwin - keep (no chance he'll be here though)

Alan Gow - punt

Stuart Carswell - punt

Cameron Howieson - punt

Stephen Mallan - keep

Scott Agnew - punt

Lewis Morgan - punt

Lewis McLear - punt

Barry Cuddihy - punt

Alex Cooper - punt

Kyle McAllister - punt

Rocco Quinn - punt


Cal Gallagher - punt

David Clarkson - punt

Lawrence Shankland - punt

Stevey Thompson - punt

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jamie Langfield - keep
Daniel Wilks - keep
Jason Naismith - punt
Sean Kelly - punt
Andy Webster - punt
Jack Baird - punt
Keith Watson - keep (but he'll get a better gig)
Jordan Stewart - punt
Gary Irvine - punt
Jim Goodwin - keep (no chance he'll be here though)
Alan Gow - punt
Stuart Carswell - punt
Cameron Howieson - punt
Stephen Mallan - keep
Scott Agnew - punt
Lewis Morgan - punt
Lewis McLear - punt
Barry Cuddihy - punt
Alex Cooper - punt
Kyle McAllister - punt
Rocco Quinn - punt
Cal Gallagher - punt
David Clarkson - punt
Lawrence Shankland - punt
Stevey Thompson - punt

Ruthless

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jamie Langfield - Punt. Worst first choice keeper I've ever seen at St Mirren. Suspect he will stay as he has a contract, let's hope it's not as first choice.

Daniel Wilks - punt. Make way for a new first choice.

Jason Naismith - keep. A fit Naismsith would be a huge asset in this league.

Sean Kelly - keep. Not had the best season but has played well in a few games. Has done enough in his time in the club to get another year. He's more a centre back than a LB.

Andy Webster - punt. Arrived with much fanfare and has been a disappointment.

Jack Baird - keep. Isn't consistent - no 20 year old defender is - but MOTM performances against Falkirk and Rangers recently show he has what it takes to be a good player at this level.

Keith Watson - keep (but he'll get a better gig). If he doesn't I'll be amazed, he's far too good for us.

Jordan Stewart - punt. Not showed enough.

Gary Irvine - punt. Has a deal for next year sadly, I think he's been very poor. Looks like his legs have gone and he just doesn't get forward to any real effect from full back.

Jim Goodwin - punt. Too old and injury prone.

Alan Gow - punt. Need I say more. One of Murrays biggest mistakes - and that's saying something!

Stuart Carswell - keep. I think there's something there. Had a few good games before his injury, most notably a MOTM performance in our win at Cappielow. Worth another year.

Cameron Howieson - punt. Not good enough.

Stephen Mallan - keep. The only bright spark in a horrific season.

Scott Agnew - punt. Back to part time football where he belongs. Not even nearly good enough.

Lewis Morgan - punt. Been overtaken by even younger players. Had chances but never got established.

Lewis McLear - punt. As above.

Barry Cuddihy - punt. As above.

Alex Cooper - punt. Very average player, certainly nothing special. Think we could do better.

Kyle McAllister - Keep. He's very young but think he could be a bit special given time.

Rocco Quinn - punt. I'd keep one of him and Carswell... For me Carswell just edges it. Rocco hasn't really done anything of note in his time here despite numerous starts.

Cal Gallagher - punt. Amazed at how many games he's started, he's rubbish. Thommo did more last night when he came on than Callum has done for weeks. Been a big disappointment.

David Clarkson - punt. Not done enough, expected more from him. Another let down.

Lawrence Shankland - punt. We need a 20 goal a season striker to lead the line next season. As the numbers show, Shankland isn't that striker. Continually fails to show up against the better teams in the league, last night being the latest example.

Thompson - is retiring.

Stevey Thompson - punt

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Smithers Jones - I suspect you have been tooooooo ruthless there - I can't see 80% of the current playing staff disappearing!

There is no way my selection of punts will happen, but based on what I have seen this season (all home games and a couple of aways) none of these players have shown me that they deserve to be here. Might seem harsh on someone like Naismith but unless he has learned to how to stop crosses into the box while he's been injured, he's included.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jamie Langfield - Punt. Worst first choice keeper I've ever seen at St Mirren. Suspect he will stay as he has a contract, let's hope it's not as first choice.

Daniel Wilks - punt. Make way for a new first choice.

Jason Naismith - keep. A fit Naismsith would be a huge asset in this league.

Sean Kelly - keep. Not had the best season but has played well in a few games. Has done enough in his time in the club to get another year. He's more a centre back than a LB.

Andy Webster - punt. Arrived with much fanfare and has been a disappointment.

Jack Baird - keep. Isn't consistent - no 20 year old defender is - but MOTM performances against Falkirk and Rangers recently show he has what it takes to be a good player at this level.

Keith Watson - keep (but he'll get a better gig). If he doesn't I'll be amazed, he's far too good for us.

Jordan Stewart - punt. Not showed enough.

Gary Irvine - punt. Has a deal for next year sadly, I think he's been very poor. Looks like his legs have gone and he just doesn't get forward to any real effect from full back.

Jim Goodwin - punt. Too old and injury prone.

Alan Gow - punt. Need I say more. One of Murrays biggest mistakes - and that's saying something!

Stuart Carswell - keep. I think there's something there. Had a few good games before his injury, most notably a MOTM performance in our win at Cappielow. Worth another year.

Cameron Howieson - punt. Not good enough.

Stephen Mallan - keep. The only bright spark in a horrific season.

Scott Agnew - punt. Back to part time football where he belongs. Not even nearly good enough.

Lewis Morgan - punt. Been overtaken by even younger players. Had chances but never got established.

Lewis McLear - punt. As above.

Barry Cuddihy - punt. As above.

Alex Cooper - punt. Very average player, certainly nothing special. Think we could do better.

Kyle McAllister - Keep. He's very young but think he could be a bit special given time.

Rocco Quinn - punt. I'd keep one of him and Carswell... For me Carswell just edges it. Rocco hasn't really done anything of note in his time here despite numerous starts.

Cal Gallagher - punt. Amazed at how many games he's started, he's rubbish. Thommo did more last night when he came on than Callum has done for weeks. Been a big disappointment.

David Clarkson - punt. Not done enough, expected more from him. Another let down.

Lawrence Shankland - punt. We need a 20 goal a season striker to lead the line next season. As the numbers show, Shankland isn't that striker. Continually fails to show up against the better teams in the league, last night being the latest example.

Thompson - is retiring.

Stevey Thompson - punt

Langfield worse first choice keeper? How long have you watched St Mirren? Worse than Scrimmy or Cornell?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...