Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

virtual west bank

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Is Our Club in Financial Difficulty ?

Featured Replies

Raising this point re finances as reading between the lines many decisions which have been made by the club recently point to cutting back on costs.

Examples:

1.Existing players being offered new contracts ( which look to be on lower terms) and not signing. Mandron being a good example having went on an SPFA trial recently.

2.Sale of players. Mcmenamin bought for £125k and sold for an "undisclosed fee." When the club quotes an undisclosed fee it is most likely to be a small fee they don't want to share but it will come out in the accounts.

3.Admin Staff leaving, being made redundant or being asked to cut their hours. Reference the departure of Lynsey McLean and Vicki Gilzean.

4.New Manager is a cheap option being promoted from an Academy Manager to Club Manager.

5.New Asst Manager Stuart Taylor leaves to work in a war Zone rather than continue at Saints.  

6.New signings are from lower league Scottish teams (withe exception of Ramos) and are used to lower wages

I may be wrong given we won the League Cup and had the share of the Scottish Cup gate money plus prize money but everything appears to point towards a cost cutting exercise across the board at this point in time.

I hope I am wrong as this looks like we are preparing for the Championship and just surviving. 

We had £1.953M in the bank at the last financial accounts published on May 31 2025.

Last season we sold Mooney and got compo for our managerial team, we won the LC & got to the semis of the SC although our League position (prize money) would've been down on recent years.

If we're in money trouble then that's an astonishing achievement by Paisley Panda & the management team.

  Fire Burning GIF by Kanpai Pandas

Edited by Bud the Baker

20 minutes ago, Bud the Baker said:

We had £1.953M in the bank at the last financial accounts published on May 31 2025.

Last season we sold Mooney and got compo for our managerial team, we won the LC & got to the semis of the SC although our League position (prize money) would've been down on recent years.

If we're in money trouble then that's an astonishing achievement by Paisley Panda & the management team.

  Fire Burning GIF by Kanpai Pandas

Ah but, but..... Etc

😉 

1 hour ago, Bud the Baker said:

We had £1.953M in the bank at the last financial accounts published on May 31 2025.

Last season we sold Mooney and got compo for our managerial team, we won the LC & got to the semis of the SC although our League position (prize money) would've been down on recent years.

If we're in money trouble then that's an astonishing achievement by Paisley Panda & the management team.

  

 

1 minute ago, James Daddy Dunlop said:

I would be happy to be wrong so give me your rationale based on what we are seeing at present

See above. 

PS please don't insult me with the tedious "I would happy to be wrong line", we all know that's not the case. 

Edited by faraway saint

13 minutes ago, James Daddy Dunlop said:

No idea why you are insulted but you are way off with "PS please don't insult me with the tedious "I would happy to be wrong line", we all know that's not the case. "

Maybe I've misjudged your post, apologies. 

  • Author

Thanks for the apology which is appreciated.

Just concerned at the information in front of us. I looked at the last set of accounts and my concern is if our expenditure remains at that level circa £7,961,374 and our income has dropped then perhaps that is the concern.

Declan John is the only player from the existing squad who has signed a new contract and the Mandron SPFA trial game seems strange.

Genuinely only want the best for the club especially as we enter our 150th anniversary.

Think the new manager and signings reflect the boards stated aim of moving to a player trading model promoting youth and the. Selling once they are developed rather than before.

 

Don't believe we are in financial difficulties but will check the next accounts as will many

1 hour ago, James Daddy Dunlop said:

I would be happy to be wrong so give me your rationale based on what we are seeing at present

He doesn’t do rationale!

Still at least you got an apology from the wee sad angry man of the forum. That’s as rare as hens teeth. 

I wouldn’t waste your time trying to have an adult conversation with him though. 

21 hours ago, James Daddy Dunlop said:

Raising this point re finances as reading between the lines many decisions which have been made by the club recently point to cutting back on costs.

Examples:

1.Existing players being offered new contracts ( which look to be on lower terms) and not signing. Mandron being a good example having went on an SPFA trial recently.

2.Sale of players. Mcmenamin bought for £125k and sold for an "undisclosed fee." When the club quotes an undisclosed fee it is most likely to be a small fee they don't want to share but it will come out in the accounts.

3.Admin Staff leaving, being made redundant or being asked to cut their hours. Reference the departure of Lynsey McLean and Vicki Gilzean.

4.New Manager is a cheap option being promoted from an Academy Manager to Club Manager.

5.New Asst Manager Stuart Taylor leaves to work in a war Zone rather than continue at Saints.  

6.New signings are from lower league Scottish teams (withe exception of Ramos) and are used to lower wages

I may be wrong given we won the League Cup and had the share of the Scottish Cup gate money plus prize money but everything appears to point towards a cost cutting exercise across the board at this point in time.

I hope I am wrong as this looks like we are preparing for the Championship and just surviving. 

To give you another view about the club, on top of what @Bud the Baker has already posted, CLEARLY giving you the financial position of the club.

1. Existing players which looks like lower terms? Can you give some proof of this? 

2. Sale of players, using McMenamin as an example who's hardly put together a full 90 decant minutes I'd suggest what ever we get is better than what we're paying him, and again, you're CHOOSING to believe it's a "small fee" when I'm assuming you don't know, strange.

3. Can't comment on admin staff as I have no proof so I'll leave that there.

4. New manager being chosen because he's cheap? Again, you have absolutely no knowledge this was the reason.

5. Taylor leaving for a club in a war zone? Brilliant take. FYI Maccabii are a very big club, finished 3rd in the Israeli league and feature regularly in Europe, unlike St Mirren. I'd suggest it's an upgrade.

6. Yes, we've signed TWO players from lower leagues and you thrown in Ramos as an afterthought. It's very early in the transfer window, I'd suggest people stay calm and keep their whining until the window is closed. You , again, come in with a comment about lower wages, interesting. 

I'd add we have an excellent board behind the scenes with Lasley being recognised as SPFL CEO of the year, not the bowling club types we've had in the past.

This is also reflective when there's next to no "rumours" leaked from the club, something that was frankly embarrassing in years gone by. 

Also we've resigned Declan John, I'm not sure he was on the cheap, I'll leave that to others to comment on. 

 

Edited by faraway saint

 

On 6/27/2026 at 10:53 AM, faraway saint said:

To give you another view about the club, on top of what @Bud the Baker has already posted, CLEARLY giving you the financial position of the club.

1. Existing players which looks like lower terms? Can you give some proof of this? 

2. Sale of players, using McMenamin as an example who's hardly put together a full 90 decant minutes I'd suggest what ever we get is better than what we're paying him, and again, you're CHOOSING to believe it's a "small fee" when I'm assuming you don't know, strange.

3. Can't comment on admin staff as I have no proof so I'll leave that there.

4. New manager being chosen because he's cheap? Again, you have absolutely no knowledge this was the reason.

5. Taylor leaving for a club in a war zone? Brilliant take. FYI Maccabii are a very big club, finished 3rd in the Israeli league and feature regularly in Europe, unlike St Mirren. I'd suggest it's an upgrade.

6. Yes, we've signed TWO players from lower leagues and you thrown in Ramos as an afterthought. It's very early in the transfer window, I'd suggest people stay calm and keep their whining until the window is closed. You , again, come in with a comment about lower wages, interesting. 

I'd add we have an excellent board behind the scenes with Lasley being recognised as SPFL CEO of the year, not the bowling club types we've had in the past.

This is also reflective when there's next to no "rumours" leaked from the club, something that was frankly embarrassing in years gone by. 

Also we've resigned Declan John, I'm not sure he was on the cheap, I'll leave that to others to comment on. 

 

Lynsey McLean is still at the club.

Edited by SamSmith99

  • Author

This will be the first of many players to leave the club based on our out of contract players being offered lower wages to stay at St.Mirren

Today, former Club Captain Mark O'Hara has rejected a contract extension with St.Mirren (on lower terms than his previous contract) and signed a new 2 year deal at former club Kilmarnock -Fact

1 minute ago, James Daddy Dunlop said:

This will be the first of many players to leave the club based on our out of contract players being offered lower wages to stay at St.Mirren

Today, former Club Captain Mark O'Hara has rejected a contract extension with St.Mirren (on lower terms than his previous contract) and signed a new 2 year deal at former club Kilmarnock -Fact

If, and the more you post I genuinely wonder where you get your information from, you had any understanding of the O'Hara situation you would KNOW he has a chronic illness which has impacted considerably his performances over the last coupla of seasons. 

As such he was offered a year contract. 

As for the Kilmarnock deal, I'm getting my popcorn out.

Oh, putting FACT after a statement really is rather foolish unless it's an actual FACT. 

🍿 🍿 🍿 

1 hour ago, SamSmith99 said:

 

Lynsey McLean is still at the club.

 

11 minutes ago, James Daddy Dunlop said:

This will be the first of many players to leave the club based on our out of contract players being offered lower wages to stay at St.Mirren

Today, former Club Captain Mark O'Hara has rejected a contract extension with St.Mirren (on lower terms than his previous contract) and signed a new 2 year deal at former club Kilmarnock -Fact

Care to respond to the Lynsey McLean statement or is that another FACT that isn't really a FACT? 🤣🤣🤣 

  • Author
6 minutes ago, faraway saint said:

 

Care to respond to the Lynsey McLean statement or is that another FACT that isn't really a FACT? 🤣🤣🤣 

Yes my mistake and my apology. Lynsey is still at the club on a circa £65k salary providing admin support and costing the club circa £80k including NIC and pension contributions. She has moved from the Kibble wage bill to ours. Good value there eh ?

10 minutes ago, James Daddy Dunlop said:

Yes my mistake and my apology. Lynsey is still at the club on a circa £65k salary providing admin support and costing the club circa £80k including NIC and pension contributions. She has moved from the Kibble wage bill to ours. Good value there eh ?

Oh, so now you're whining about the cost when you mentioned, quite gleefully, she'd been made redundant or asked to cut her hours?

How, exactly, do you know her salary details? 

Sorry mate, away and gies peace, you've no credibility and you really should be more careful what lies, or misleading, information, you post. 

Cannie wait for the Kilmarnock deal details to hit you. :lol:

Edited by faraway saint

James Daddy Dunlop, I did warn you about trying to have an adult conversation with the forum fruitcake. He's the reason this forum has little to no proper debate and why there is hardly anyone left using it. You will note that most of the threads are just him talking to himself. 

70,227 🤪 ( I know it's hard to believe isn't it?) posts mainly of abuse and trying to put people down. He clearly gets off on it. Sad and miserable beyond words.

 

 

 

47 minutes ago, Mr Optimistic said:

James Daddy Dunlop, I did warn you about trying to have an adult conversation with the forum fruitcake. He's the reason this forum has little to no proper debate and why there is hardly anyone left using it. You will note that most of the threads are just him talking to himself. 

70,227 🤪 ( I know it's hard to believe isn't it?) posts mainly of abuse and trying to put people down. He clearly gets off on it. Sad and miserable beyond words.

 

 

 

Can you point out what isn't adult about my posts rather than doing what you do all the time, whine like a baby girl? :1eye

Try adding something to the conversation rather than regurgitation the number of posts I have, although I do love that it gets you extremely upset. :lol:

PS Could you please add on my 700+ posts from P&B? :thumbs2

Edited by faraway saint
Strong language, he might cry.

3 hours ago, James Daddy Dunlop said:

This will be the first of many players to leave the club based on our out of contract players being offered lower wages to stay at St.Mirren

Today, former Club Captain Mark O'Hara has rejected a contract extension with St.Mirren (on lower terms than his previous contract) and signed a new 2 year deal at former club Kilmarnock -Fact

FFS, another apology, I misread in my haste, this a three year deal, feck knows how, hence I was doubting the length of contract offered by Killie. 

That's two, imagine that. 🙄 

3 hours ago, faraway saint said:

Can you point out what isn't adult about my posts rather than doing what you do all the time, whine like a baby girl? :1eye

Try adding something to the conversation rather than regurgitation the number of posts I have, although I do love that it gets you extremely upset. :lol:

PS Could you please add on my 700+ posts from P&B? :thumbs2

The idea you think ANYTHING the Forum Fruitcake says or does on here would upset me says much more about you than me. 😁🤣

With pleasure....Around SEVENTY ONE THOUSAND posts on football forums!🤣 Boy you must have some life. 

 

1 minute ago, Mr Optimistic said:

The idea you think ANYTHING the Forum Fruitcake says or does on here would upset me says much more about you than me. 😁🤣

With pleasure....Around SEVENTY ONE THOUSAND posts on football forums!🤣 Boy you must have some life. 

 

Rattled. 🤣🤣🤣 

As usual, absolutely nothing, just the usual dreary repetitive drivel.  🤡 

Edited by faraway saint

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.