Are you ITK?
As Hearts are Scotland's 3rd biggest club, you would hope that he would get them promoted! Especially as he had Craig Levein holding has hand, signing the players and picking the team!
Once he no longer had Levein to hold his hand, he flopped.
The fact that he wasn't as big a flop as McInnes or Clarke, in your opinion, or that Goodwin might hypothetically get bagged in England one day, in your opinion, aren't selling points for me!
If we took your logic, we'd never have appointed Jack Ross in the first place! :lol: