Yesterday was a massive kick in the stones, but we can't blame it all on the officials. Our finishing, tight calls going against us, flat atmosphere and lack of experience were all frustrating factors to our defeat. Harkin's 'tackle' on Tess in the first minute was a shocker. Just a talking to from Steven McLean?? We say it all the time, but if that had been Goodie.....
We were the better team in the first half, playing with confidence and outplaying a Dundee side, that has over achieved this season. I believe that we have better football players, but Dundee are streetwise, something that we really lack. A prime example being when Gary Irvine saw his team were in a dangerous situation, as Naismith gathered the ball in the Dundee box(1st half), so Irvine completely faked a head knock, and the conned ref wrongly stopped play and gave a drop ball. The result being, after the drop ball, a frustrated Naismith needlessly challenges Kevin Thomson(odious cheat) as we have them pegged in. Thomson throws himself to the deck, clutching his back??? and writhing in agony, after next to no contact. End result - from Saints having the ball in their box in a really great position, Dundee have a free kick, Thomson jogs away with a miraculous recovery and grinning and Naismith is needlessly booked. Cheating or clever gamesmanship by Irvine and the total knob Thomson? The answer is both and hopefully Naismith learned from it.
I agree that Kenny McLean got no protection from the ref yesterday and they were blatantly going through the back of Kenny on numerous occasions. Early on Kenny went down far too easily then berated the ref, which I believe influenced the future decisions that went against him. Obviously this isn't right on the refs part, but another example of a situation where a bit more savvy was needed by Kenny. Get the ref on your side early doors(even before kick off), crack a joke with him, friendly chat, pat on the back etc, etc.. don't scream and moan at him(even if he is a twat), as it only results in future decisions going against you. I wonder if Harkins had taken this approach before his assault on Tess??
Another factor yesterday, which has been mentioned many times on this site, is the complete lack of atmosphere at our 'new' ground. When Dundee equalised the place became a morgue and had an air of understandable inevitability about it. I don't know how we can fix this, but a couple of home victories seems like the best medicine. We still wait in hope for one home victory.
Hopefully with a bit more experience our young team can become more streetwise and quickly. There is a blurred line between cheating and being clever, but unfortunately it has always been part of the game. Scottish fans still celebrate Joe Jordon's handball against Wales, a defining factor to us getting to the 78 World Cup Finals. As a kid, I remember watching the master of cleverness at Love Street, Frank McGarvey. He was brilliant at winning free kicks/penalties, winding the opposition up(see Hamish McAlpine),creating space and scoring clever goals.
We still have a lot of positives at our club, Stevie Mallandona being a prime example. As well as his obvious talent and ability, he has a wee bit of guile and cleverness about him that some of his senior team mates could learn from.
The club are now seeking an explanation from the SFA on the standard of refereeing and recent decisions going against us. This will achieve nothing, as it's not going to get us the points we lost back and will give us a reputation of being paranoid moaners. There is no widespread agenda against us, we just need to be 'cuter', week in, week out. We also need a big change in the terrible luck we are having at the moment.
Hopefully on Friday our luck will change and we will focus on being a bit more 'clever', rather than feeling sorry for ourselves, which although warranted at the moment, will achieve absolutely nothing.