Knightswoodsaint

I would like to apologise for any offence caused and retract the above comment I’m not exactly sure what I was trying to say. I never have and never would abuse a woman and certainly do not condone it in any shape or form. If I knew how to delete the aforementioned comment I would. Again apapologies to all on the forum

Why would cammy be dropped different roles different positions

For me none of our centre half pairings have looked good or comfortable so I don’t see why Cole is being singled out what in my opinion any of the 3 need is to be paired with an experienced central defender in games. Cole is only 22 Baird is only 22 Jones is still only 20 for me none of the 3 are natural leaders on the park at centre half Gary Mac could be the answer when he is back fit or for now Ferdinand if he signs and clearly OK knows this as he is looking for another CH

In my opinion people in this country view the Danske bank premier league as a diddy league but our league is viewed in the same way across Europe so in essence he is moving from one diddy league to another and I believe he is no longer a full time school teacher and part time football manager he is now the manager of our team St Mirren and as so deserves the respect and backing of us as supporters to do the best job he can in our own diddy league

For the record and only my opinion he clearly had no clue. No formation, no tactics, blaming everyone but himself including the hearts defeat.to which he blamed the defence as individuals Although he signed 4 from the back 5 that played on Saturday. His record at Hibs was abysmal ie couldn’t get out of the championship. Got lucky in the cup ( yeah every club needs luck in a knockout competition) then jumps ship to Rotherham and subsequently get the sack ( for pretty much the same as here) yet you critique the board. Are you really being serious Tam ??? Ie tam McManus

Least season is irrelevant now people keeping bringing up Livi this season if you take the bigger games away we have played Dundee and Livi and in my opinion most people would have settled for 4 points from those 2 games probably expecting the 3 to come from the Livi game. We at present have 3 from those 6 available so at worst 1 point short of most people’s thoughts before season kicked off

There may well be problems but the team is in transition and lets be honest it was common knowledge Ross was going and the knew this as well yet they dilly dallied around getting a replacement. We got out of the group stages for a change albeit the group stars are almost pre season games as we had none. And as for that public display by our club captain nothing short of petulant. It’s a captains responsibility to try and make the team as cohesive as possible on the park not use it and the game as a public defiance of sorts and for the record I’m a massive mcginn fan. No matter what goes on at training or in the corridors of the stadium they stay there

Is this the same Livingston team that also beat Hibs yesterday Stubbs should be given the time to play at least every team in the division. The board in my opinion are simply not going to sack him after playing rangers and hearts away in the league Aberdeen away in the cup. Celtic up next and won one lost one against teams that will no doubt be around us this season.

I must admit I am not nor ever have been a Stubbs fan as a manager but as already mentioned given our start Celtic Rangers and hearts in our first 5 league games with Aberdeen away thrown in for good measure in the cup he needs to be given the first quarter then it can be looked at. GLS will not get rid this early given the opposition we have played in the league and are about to in our next game. This is a team in transition and yes looks very disjointed right now and maybe Stubbs isn’t the man for the job but does anyone really think the board are going to bag the manager at this precise moment.

They as you will notice also beat Hibs yesterday and as it stands are 3rd in the league. I must admit I am not nor ever have been a Stubbs fan as a manager but as already mentioned given our start Celtic Rangers and hearts in our first 5 league games with Aberdeen away thrown in for good measure in the cup he needs to be given the first quarter then it can be looked at. GLS will not get rid this early given the opposition we have played in the league and are about to in our next game.

Not necessarily if the player on the years contract plays well they have put themselves in the shop window to other clubs who will no doubt offer more than say ourselves thus move on the loanee if he performs yes shows his parent club they are good worst case again puts themselves in the same shop window to try get the best deal possible. As it stands the loanee market can open up players we may not alternately had a sniff at. Hodson for example willlock will come good ok maybe others we missed out on Stewart going to Killie so for me they are similar markets as both players are ultimately trying to impress for at worse selfish reasons that’s football

Another thread about loanee players. As mentioned on the other thread is there really that much difference from a 1 year loan player to a player on a 1 year contract