This is definitely a position we needed a player for.
Goodwin was our only defensive midfielder. You need at least 2, particularly if Goodwin us suspended or used in defence.
I always hark back to the 80s but all the best sided had 2 hard working midfielders who got no praise and did the dirty work.
Cooper & Simpson at Aberdeen, Kirkwood & Stark at Dundee Utd, Black & Berry at Hearts.
Motherwell released a similar no nonsense player over 20 years ago. Did the dirty work, made the simple pass. He went on to join a second tier club, helped them win promotion then had a great top flight career.
His name was Mark Reilly.
Hopefully Carswell will be as good.
At the very least he'll be a decent squad player with all the top flight experience he has.
No risk signing, think this is ok.