Mid Calder Saint

In answer to Sonny with whom I usually respect his views how many attend Hamilton against the likes of Ross County Livi or fake Saints in the current format the answer is a little over 1000 if you are lucky no I want a larger league simply because I am fed up playing the same teams five or six times a year if you include cup games I have and always will be a campaigner for a larger league

Abandon promotion and relegation perfect opportunity for league reconstruction top league of 16 teams 30 games and get rid of the ridiculous split

Great result on to Killie now

Just shows the pure folly of only having two inexperienced centre backs absolutely no defenders on bench just so so unprofessional

Well beaten Celtic didn’t break sweat we are a rudderless ship from top to bottom those players are an utter disgrace to the jersey no fight no desire and no tactics whatsoever from an utterly clueless manager we are a Championship club at best being outdone by the likes of Livi who sell under 900 season tickets time for change now little point in waiting any longer

Marking is absolutely shocking what does Goodwin actually do with those players at training Waters is hopeless constantly gets caught in possession and just cannot seem to mark his man we are meant to be full time pros to me we look like a bunch is clueless amateurs Goodwin totally out of his depth you wonder if those players care about the club or their own careers or realise the position we are in

Observe that no academy players in the starting line up of course two on the bench no real sign of breakthrough from others worrying times I would say.

Why did we not use all four subs like Well! Jim’s main problem is the squads inbalance a couple of defenders on bench would have enabled us to shore up defence to help our young centre backs this has to be addressed immediately.

I feel the question of budget is used as an excuse far too often in my opinion Livi’s recruitment has been far superior to us for a while now no question Livi can’t pay huge salaries their season ticket sales are around 800 but they seem to get right good hungry players in the door like the boy Dykes from Queens surely we should have been for this player and the guy Lawless from Partick add the boy Pittman signed from Broxburn

This squad is so severely unbalanced you wonder we ever allowed the likes of Baird to go out on loan McKenzie quite frankly is a complete liability in terms of his fitness he is just never available the Manager has just wasted the transfer window for me being left short of defenders and ending up with six strikers.We now have total lack of cover in defence.

Alex Bruce ??

Welcome aboard Akin

I am presently living in Spain and watching Saints games on tv I know we got our goal in the 89th minute but was really upset that the ref only allowed two mins added time given the stoppages incl subs etc I would have said there was at least five mins minimum just feel this was a guess by the ref I watch a lot of matches from England including the Premier League and Championship I watched Leeds v PNE last night when with no injuries the ref played six mins added time just don’t think our refs are up to the mark

Well Sonny you hit the nail there Goody is firmly out of his depth.

Goody this and Goody that totally but totally out of his depth.How may candidates did the Board interview in the summer? What does Gus do to cover his salary? Recruitment has been truly awful we are only headed in one direction and the ever so loyal fans are being short changed again.Scott I feel is not up the job as Chairman of our great Football Club and the sooner he is gone the better he does not have the necessary pedigree to run a successful Football Club.A club of our size should certainly be able to compete favourably with a club like Motherwell who are similar in size to ourselves.