I know its all about opinions but I'd love to know what you base this on? Lets be honest most fans knew nothing about Craig McLeish until recently.  Players rate him? How do you know that? He has done well? The Rangers game was as bad as we have been all season. Docherty had NO impact at Aberdeen, why would we want him? And Park joined St Mirren in June 2025 but you say his recruitment has dipped over the last few YEARS? He's only been here 8 months. Thank God fans aren't involved with the recruitment of new managers. Lets hope the board know a little more about everyone involved than we do.

I won't be abusing him from the terraces. I don't see the point. He did well for us and he left for a bigger club with a bigger budget and a bigger pay packet. Neither will I be heralding him as he left us in a very precarious position. He is the manager of our opposition and, as such, I will be there to support OUR management and our team.

I agree I'd go with McLeish till the end of the season. Players rate him and in the 2 games he has had in charge he has done well. Docherty linked as assistant and I'd go for that although doing fine with the guys we have, do we need another voice ? No to Robinson from me. Park's recruitment of players seems to have dipped over the last few years, never mind a manager.