There is no logic in picking a best XI of the last 50 years. The best in their position? Ian Munro and Billy Stark were the most intelligent football players I've seen in the jersey, Tony Fitz the biggest heart, Doug Somner the bravest ....... I could go on. Most will pick their favourite XI 'cos that's what being a football fan is all about and I could fill a page with favourites since the early 60's, most of whom don't meet the 50 year gap. Ally McLeod scoring 4 at Ibrox is possibly the best performace in a Saints jersey I have ever seen. Victor was a class act, unfortunately not in the Black and White. Apart from McGowan I don't disagree with any of the names put forward (good enough player but I don't think he matches up to others named here). So don't get your knickers in a twist just remember the pleasure you got watching them play the beautiful game.