shull 30,573 Report post Posted September 30 (edited) Not necessarily the best football players you have seen but players you liked and admired in the black and white. They may have been below par skill wise but fought hard for the cause. Mine...... Manager - Danny Lennon 1. Danny Stevenson 2. Sandy Cleland 3. John Mowat 4. Tony Fitzpatrick 5. Gordon McQueen 6. Willie Fulton 7. Bobby McKean 8. Billy Stark 9. Dougie Somner 10. Lex Richardson. 11. Jackie McGillivray Beat that. Edited September 30 by shull 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
shull 30,573 Report post Posted September 30 Had to edit. Cleland for Beckett. Great dude was Sandy Cleland. Although, not a better player than Beckett. 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
shull 30,573 Report post Posted September 30 Come on Smokie and Oaky. Give us your favourite all time players. 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
chalky1 1,107 Report post Posted September 30 (edited) Kind of remember Fergie but early 80's started going to games with my mates, so plenty I can't remember Manager - Alex Miller - for consistency of cup runs and challenging for Europe 1) Campbell Money 2) Tommy Wilson 3)Stevie Clarke 4)Tony Fitzpatrick 5) Neal Cooper 6) Paul Fenwick 7)Billie Abercrombie 8 Billy Stark 9) Frank McGarvey 10) Frank McAvennie 11) Peter Weir  Subs 12) Gunni 13) Lavetty 14) Mark Fulton 15) Doug Somner 16) Jackie Copland 17) Paul Lambert 18) Hinchcliffe  Probably found it easier to name a squad you didn't like Shull Potter and Elliott would be my Captian and VC, lol   Edited September 30 by chalky1 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
smcc 1,223 Report post Posted September 30 Dibble starting and on the bench? 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
chalky1 1,107 Report post Posted September 30 8 minutes ago, smcc said: Dibble starting and on the bench? Whoops, he's like the boy De Boer, so good you'd think there where 2 of them 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
shull 30,573 Report post Posted September 30 19 minutes ago, chalky1 said: Kind of remember Fergie but early 80's started going to games with my mates, so plenty I can't remember Manager - Alex Miller - for consistency of cup runs and challenging for Europe 1) Campbell Money 2) Tommy Wilson 3)Stevie Clarke 4)Tony Fitzpatrick 5) Neal Cooper 6) Paul Fenwick 7)Billie Abercrombie 8 Billy Stark 9) Frank McGarvey 10) Frank McAvennie 11) Peter Weir  Subs 12) Gunni 13) Lavetty 14) Mark Fulton 15) Doug Somner 16) Jackie Copland 17) Paul Lambert 18) Hinchcliffe  Probably found it easier to name a squad you didn't like Shull Potter and Elliott would be my Captian and VC, lol   Potter & Elliott  ? I liked Potter. 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
uhura 184 Report post Posted September 30 Victor is the best player ever to have played for St.Mirren 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Slarti 359 Report post Posted September 30 Victor is the best player ever to have played for St.MirrenWith Elliott a close second. 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
cambiebud 1,037 Report post Posted October 1 ConaghanWilsonMunroFitzpatrick ReidMcGinn JHewittStarkMcDougallThorfasonMcGarvey 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
God of war 27 Report post Posted October 1 19 hours ago, uhura said: Victor is the best player ever to have played for St.Mirren Victor in his day would hsve been the best player but not anywhere near it when he came to Saints. Still was very good but have enjoyed watching other players more. Scanlon and Copland my two favourites. Mcdougall and Macca upfront was a joy. Now we have Morias and McAllister😓😓😓 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
TPAFKA Jersey 2 3,538 Report post Posted October 1 3 hours ago, God of war said: Victor in his day would hsve been the best player but not anywhere near it when he came to Saints. Still was very good but have enjoyed watching other players more. Scanlon and Copland my two favourites. Mcdougall and Macca upfront was a joy. Now we have Morias and McAllister😓😓😓 Agreed. Victor was obviously still a very good player when he came to us, but not even in my top 5 best players in the stripes. McAvennie no. 1 for me. 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Prague Buddie 350 Report post Posted October 1 (edited)               Money       Aitken  Turner  Cooper                Aber Teale     Victor  Fitzy.     Weir      McAvennie.  McGarvey  Subs. Roy, , Fulton, Munro, Richardson, Scanlon, Torfason, McDougall. Manager. Tom Hendre (Simply for the bubble disnae burst season) Edited October 1 by Prague Buddie 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Helmettroll 194 Report post Posted October 1 Money Clarke Munro Copeland Fulton Stark Fitzpatrick Ferguson McAvennie McGarvey Weir  Subs. Hladky Cooper Beckett Richardson McGinn. John Morgan Somner.  What a team that would be, if only...    0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Hendo 2,865 Report post Posted October 1 3 minutes ago, Helmettroll said: Money Clarke Munro Copeland Fulton Stark Fitzpatrick Ferguson McAvennie McGarvey Weir  Subs. Hladky Cooper Beckett Richardson McGinn. John Morgan Somner.  What a team that would be, if only...    Pretty much nailed it. I'd probably have Thomson in for Money, as thought he was a better all round keeper, cup semis aside, and Beckett maybe for Munro (whose reputation took a hit after walking away from the managers job). 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
thepaisleypanda 618 Report post Posted October 1 Nobody including Norrie Mchwirter??? - Not the best EVER, but clasically consistent! 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Eric Arthur Blair 5,942 Report post Posted October 1 Money Clarke Munro Reid Copland Fitzpatrick Stark Scanlon Weir McGarvey Somner No one from 87 onwards because no one from 87 onwards could lace the boots of that 11. (maybe Hladlky). 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
TPAFKA Jersey 2 3,538 Report post Posted October 1 11 minutes ago, Eric Arthur Blair said: Money Clarke Munro Reid Copland Fitzpatrick Stark Scanlon Weir McGarvey Somner No one from 87 onwards because no one from 87 onwards could lace the boots of that 11. (maybe Hladlky). 100% agree with the exception of somehow managing to fit McAvennie in. The OP though talked about players that you just loved, even if they weren’t necessarily good enough to get in an 11 purely on ability. On that basis I’d have to add Richardson, Torrance, Beckett and Wilson (Tommy). 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Eric Arthur Blair 5,942 Report post Posted October 1 9 minutes ago, TPAFKA Jersey 2 said: 100% agree with the exception of somehow managing to fit McAvennie in. The OP though talked about players that you just loved, even if they weren’t necessarily good enough to get in an 11 purely on ability. On that basis I’d have to add Richardson, Torrance, Beckett and Wilson (Tommy). yeah, maybe Macca for Scanners...and as for the other 4 you mention they were far superior to the vast majority we've had since those halcyon days. 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Eric Arthur Blair 5,942 Report post Posted October 1 12 minutes ago, TPAFKA Jersey 2 said: The OP though talked about players... The OP is on ignore. 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
God of war 27 Report post Posted October 2 13 hours ago, Prague Buddie said:               Money       Aitken  Turner  Cooper                Aber Teale     Victor  Fitzy.     Weir      McAvennie.  McGarvey  Subs. Roy, , Fulton, Munro, Richardson, Scanlon, Torfason, McDougall. Manager. Tom Hendre (Simply for the bubble disnae burst season) Turner, Aitken and Cooper over Copland???? U mad😛 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
shull 30,573 Report post Posted October 2 22 minutes ago, God of war said: Turner, Aitken and Cooper over Copland???? U mad😛 It's not about best player. All about the individual forumsters favourite player. The player could be good, bad or indifferent at playing the game. I picked Cleland and Mowat in my Team. They weren't outstanding players but were cult heroes to me. 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Prague Buddie 350 Report post Posted October 2 (edited) 4 hours ago, God of war said: Turner, Aitken and Cooper over Copland???? U mad😛 To be honest, I don't remember ever seeing Copland play (although, I did) , that's why he isn't there. I was quite young in those days. I remember Weir (especially 2nd time), Scanlon and Macca, but not Copland. Back in those days I was between the age of 5 - 10, so only ever paid attention to the exciting wingers and goalscorers. Turner, Cooper and Aitken were more from the era when I started to appreciate defenders aswell. Edited October 2 by Prague Buddie 0 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
billyg 5,669 Report post Posted October 2 Connaghan  Beckett Rogerson Copland H McLaughlin  Richardson Borthwick Abercromby  McKean Kane Scanlon  Subs - Adamson , Blair , Somner , A McLeod , Johnston  1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
windae cleaner 3,920 Report post Posted October 2 Going by Shull rules Thompson T Wilson McCormick Copland Munro Clarke Ferguson Stark Weir Macavennie McGarvey 2 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
