Speculation Thread

[ALBIONSAINT 1,932]

36 minutes ago, RossCSmfc said:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sam_Foley

He sounds a bit like Goodwin, might be good sitting in front of defence. 

[St.Ricky 8,274]

12 minutes ago, FTOF said:

Seems the NTFC fans were pretty disappointed that he was released. They seemed to think that he was their best midfielder by a mile.

Yeovil Town and Port Vale fans seem keen to have him back.

 

Strange thing to say perhaps, but I trust JG and GM to make sound decisions on the shape of the side and personnel they need. 

[djchapsticks 9,491]

12 minutes ago, FTOF said:

Seems the NTFC fans were pretty disappointed that he was released. They seemed to think that he was their best midfielder by a mile.

Yeovil Town and Port Vale fans seem keen to have him back.

 

Think it's easy to forget as everyone is focused on positions where we have no-one, that centre mid probably does need someone better in there as well and it goes back to what I said earlier....no issue with folk going if they aren't as good as who comes in.

We are absolutely top heavy with central players at present but Stevie McGinn has looked well off the pace, Kyle Magennis and Ryan Flynn have started poorly (expect both to rally without issue though)and Kellerman doesn't look nearly good enough.

If someone can come into the middle of the park with a bit of technical ability, it would make a lot of difference, I was concerned about the no pace part of his assessment but if he's as hard working as is mentioned and can provide a bit of box-to-box energy (a type of Steven Thomson player - another guy who had very little pace) then it could well be a  good thing for us regardless of how many others can play his position.

Definitely, if he is coming in though, it's time to move others on. Ethan or Cammy might benefit from a loan elsewhere in the short term. Tansey, we can now accept is probably not coming back and Jim Kellerman doesn't appear to be suitable for any midfield role I've seen him tried out in.

[Stu 3,444]

We could have given Halkett the 75k as a signing on fee and it would still have made a massive amount more sense. Big error, that one.

I seem to remember a story on here that Ross had agreed to sign Halkett (although it may have been another Livi defender) and Stubbs cancelled it.

 

As for Kellerman, sure Goodwin said that he has dislocated his shoulder so maybe that's why we're looking at another midfielder.

 

[Sonny 9,414]

6 minutes ago, Stu said:

I seem to remember a story on here that Ross had agreed to sign Halkett (although it may have been another Livi defender) and Stubbs cancelled it.

As for Kellerman, sure Goodwin said that he has dislocated his shoulder.

I heard the same Stu. Halkett was coming to us but when Ross left and during the uncertainty he signed on again for Livi.

[Magic Monkey 4,688]

11 minutes ago, Stu said:

I seem to remember a story on here that Ross had agreed to sign Halkett (although it may have been another Livi defender) and Stubbs cancelled it.

As for Kellerman, sure Goodwin said that he has dislocated his shoulder.

I know MacPherson dislocated his... Sounds like a pandemic.

I did mine 13 times. It's a f**king nightmare and you can't come back quickly from it.

[faraway saint 32,998]

2 minutes ago, Magic Monkey said:

I know MacPherson dislocated his... Sounds like a pandemic.

I did mine 13 times. It's a f**king nightmare and you can't come back quickly from it.

Does this mean your fecked on plastic pitches? 

[magnus 3,080]

26 minutes ago, djchapsticks said:

Think it's easy to forget as everyone is focused on positions where we have no-one, that centre mid probably does need someone better in there as well and it goes back to what I said earlier....no issue with folk going if they aren't as good as who comes in.

We are absolutely top heavy with central players at present but Stevie McGinn has looked well off the pace, Kyle Magennis and Ryan Flynn have started poorly (expect both to rally without issue though)and Kellerman doesn't look nearly good enough.

If someone can come into the middle of the park with a bit of technical ability, it would make a lot of difference, I was concerned about the no pace part of his assessment but if he's as hard working as is mentioned and can provide a bit of box-to-box energy (a type of Steven Thomson player - another guy who had very little pace) then it could well be a  good thing for us regardless of how many others can play his position.

Definitely, if he is coming in though, it's time to move others on. Ethan or Cammy might benefit from a loan elsewhere in the short term. Tansey, we can now accept is probably not coming back and Jim Kellerman doesn't appear to be suitable for any midfield role I've seen him tried out in.

What is the position with Tansey? Is he out of contract or sacked or what? Looks like Tansey feels he has a chance of recovering 100% from this bone disease that has plagued him and he feels he can be a decent player again. Has Tansey fallen out with Gordon Scott or Jim. Another strange circumstance

 

[djchapsticks 9,491]

6 minutes ago, magnus said:

What is the position with Tansey? Is he out of contract or sacked or what? Looks like Tansey feels he has a chance of recovering 100% from this bone disease that has plagued him and he feels he can be a decent player again. Has Tansey fallen out with Gordon Scott or Jim. Another strange circumstance

 

I've commented on what I think is happening with Tansey over on his thread.

Just my opinion and reading between the lines of what he has said himself but long story short, I think he genuinely believes he's fit and recovered but specialists won't clear him as they disagree that he's OK and we as a club are siding with the specialists on this.

[Mid Calder Saint 1,511]

The situation is we badly need a tall defensive central midfielder who can dictate play and shield the defence preferably a good sound fit journeyman type with a decent fitness record just like Goody himself this ex Northampton guy appears to fit the bill.

[Johnny Rep 192]

57 minutes ago, FTOF said:

Seems the NTFC fans were pretty disappointed that he was released. They seemed to think that he was their best midfielder by a mile.

Yeovil Town and Port Vale fans seem keen to have him back.

 

And your point is caller ?

[djchapsticks 9,491]

4 minutes ago, Johnny Rep said:

And your point is caller ?

I'm guessing that supporters of League One and Two level clubs seem to think he's of a good enough standard?

So not a kick in the arse off of our level really.

Edited July 27, 2019 by djchapsticks

[FTOF 11,790]

31 minutes ago, Stu said:

I seem to remember a story on here that Ross had agreed to sign Halkett (although it may have been another Livi defender) and Stubbs cancelled it.

 

As for Kellerman, sure Goodwin said that he has dislocated his shoulder so maybe that's why we're looking at another midfielder.

 

It was a guy I know who spoke to Halkett and he confirmed that he was joining us until Stubbs pulled the deal.

[FTOF 11,790]

1 minute ago, djchapsticks said:

I'm guessing that supporters of League One and Two level clubs seem to thing he's of a good enough standard?

So not a kick in the arse off of our level really.

Yeah.

I didn't think it was that hard to understand.

[djchapsticks 9,491]

2 minutes ago, FTOF said:

It was a guy I know who spoke to Halkett and he confirmed that he was joining us until Stubbs pulled the deal.

That's disastrous.

 

I knew it was claimed but didn't realise that it was confirmed. Still.....all's well that ends well and we got a cracking young centre half from the V9 instead. 

[Hendo 3,079]

55 minutes ago, ALBIONSAINT said:

He sounds a bit like Goodwin, might be good sitting in front of defence. 

Not sure he's a defensive midfielder, seems to have scored a lot of goals, especially at Newport, if that's his position.

[FTOF 11,790]

Just now, Hendo said:

Not sure he's a defensive midfielder, seems to have scored a lot of goals, especially at Newport, if that's his position.

Maybe he scores a lot goals from long distance .🙄

[djchapsticks 9,491]

13 minutes ago, Hendo said:

Not sure he's a defensive midfielder, seems to have scored a lot of goals, especially at Newport, if that's his position.

He played as a winger for Newport. Has moved into the middle in the last 3 or 4 years where he's being described as 'combative'. 

[jaybee 1,770]

10 hours ago, djchapsticks said:

Allegedly Cammy Smith is free to leave Dundee Utd. 

I await the cries of 'bring him home' from the usual suspects, despite the fact that he is nowhere near good enough for the premier league. 

So what his Mum loves him and you know what you may be right but as a freebie signing could be worth a punt?  

[Big Yards 1,011]

We should offer Michael Moffat of Ayr a 1 year contract.  Scores for fun in the championship. Another goal today in the league cup 

Edited July 27, 2019 by Big Yards

[djchapsticks 9,491]

12 minutes ago, Big Yards said:

We should offer Michael Moffat of Ayr a 1 year contract.  Scores for fun in the championship. Another goal today in the league cup 

He's 34 years old and scored 5 in 34 last season in the championship. 

For fun, aye.

Sometimes I think you actually WANT us to get relegated. 

[Dan Is The Man 741]

YouTube Compilation! Get in! Even if it’s just for the tune! He does certainly look like a sitting midfielder that’s comfortable in the tackle.

[djchapsticks 9,491]

2 minutes ago, Dan Is The Man said:

 

 

YouTube Compilation! Get in! Even if it’s just for the tune! He does certainly look like a sitting midfielder that’s comfortable in the tackle.

 

After being historically quite spoiled in that regard, we've not had a player who can truly effectively do that sort of dirty work for a long time. 

The prospect of this guy coming in makes a lot more sense. 

[windae cleaner 4,189]

A sitting midfielder

Gus favourite type of signing

[Isle Of Bute Saint 9,963]

1 hour ago, magnus said:

What is the position with Tansey? Is he out of contract or sacked or what? Looks like Tansey feels he has a chance of recovering 100% from this bone disease that has plagued him and he feels he can be a decent player again. Has Tansey fallen out with Gordon Scott or Jim. Another strange circumstance

 

It's going to be another pay off the contract deals we have become so good at.