John McGinn

[TPAFKA Jersey 2 2,184]

4 hours ago, Drew said:

BBC are reporting that Forest are expected to come in with a new bid for McGinn by Thursday.

My guess is that they'll up the bid to a million quid, and Hibs, quite justifiably, will tell them to get tae. So I don't expect any windfall for Saints from a sale this window.

Oh well, we can win this league without it

 

Surely Hibs will have said to Forest something along the lines of "Your bid isn't even remotely close, so unless you're prepared to get serious, don't bother wasting any more of our time or yours.".

[Drew 21,115]

11 minutes ago, TPAFKA Jersey 2 said:

Surely Hibs will have said to Forest something along the lines of "Your bid isn't even remotely close, so unless you're prepared to get serious, don't bother wasting any more of our time or yours.".

Brinksmanship.

I'm guessing Notts won't up their bid by a great deal on the basis that they reckon Hibs might blink first.

Edited August 29, 2017 by Drew

[TPAFKA Jersey 2 2,184]

Just now, Drew said:

Brinkmanship.

Yeah but brinkmanship usually only pays off if you are in remotely the same ballpark. Surely if Forest come back with something like £1m, Hibs will just tell them to do one. Hibs aren't in any rush to sell are they? I don't believe they need £1m that desperately.

[Drew 21,115]

1 minute ago, TPAFKA Jersey 2 said:

Yeah but brinkmanship usually only pays off if you are in remotely the same ballpark. Surely if Forest come back with something like £1m, Hibs will just tell them to do one. Hibs aren't in any rush to sell are they? I don't believe they need £1m that desperately.

Aye, I agree that Hibs will chase them.

I'm not sure that Notts would jump from £750K to, say, £2M, which is what I reckon Hibs would be looking for at the very least.

[Frank McGarvey' wonky legs 1,051]

Jackson Irvine in the process of going for 1.5 million there is your minimum benchmark

[HSS 10,613]

33 minutes ago, Drew said:

Brinksmanship.

I'm guessing Notts won't up their bid by a great deal on the basis that they reckon Hibs might blink first.

Notts are County....Forest are Nottingham.

[faraway saint 22,375]

5 minutes ago, Frank McGarvey' wonky legs said:

Jackson Irvine in the process of going for 1.5 million there is your minimum benchmark

I would suggest there's plenty of differences between Irvine and McGinn and also Hull have a massive payment for dropping from the top league.

13 caps for Australia, 10 gals in a much higher league than McGinn has played in would suggest he's a bargain for £1.5

TBH maybe it's more a  case of Irvine is a steal than a true reflection of what McGinn is worth.

[djchapsticks 6,906]

4 minutes ago, faraway saint said:

I would suggest there's plenty of differences between Irvine and McGinn and also Hull have a massive payment for dropping from the top league.

13 caps for Australia, 10 gals in a much higher league than McGinn has played in would suggest he's a bargain for £1.5

TBH maybe it's more a  case of Irvine is a steal than a true reflection of what McGinn is worth.

I saw plenty of Jackson Irvine with both Ross County and Killie to suggest that he's nowhere near as good as McGinn.

But then, you don't have to be that good to attract a 7 figure fee between two English clubs anymore. It's just Scottish clubs they can insult with shite bids. 

[faraway saint 22,375]

9 minutes ago, djchapsticks said:

I saw plenty of Jackson Irvine with both Ross County and Killie to suggest that he's nowhere near as good as McGinn.

But then, you don't have to be that good to attract a 7 figure fee between two English clubs anymore. It's just Scottish clubs they can insult with shite bids. 

That was then, this is now.

As I said, he proven himself in a higher league, bargain at £1.5

[shull 27,738]

Just say naw. 

And put a fixed price on him. 

 

[shull 27,738]

1 hour ago, HSS said:

Notts are County....Forest are Nottingham.

Indeed 

Every football fan knows that 

[Stu 3,239]

2 hours ago, Frank McGarvey' wonky legs said:

Jackson Irvine in the process of going for 1.5 million there is your minimum benchmark

Bit worried if Burton Albion are coming into cash considering they were in for Morgan earlier in the summer.

[munoz 5,326]

7 minutes ago, Stu said:

Bit worried if Burton Albion are coming into cash considering they were in for Morgan earlier in the summer.

£1.5m for Morgan then . No less .

[DougJamie 5,391]

3 minutes ago, munoz said:

£1.5m for Morgan then . No less .

Think that would be a record by a mile for a second tier Scot. We cant command that.............. best we can hope for is 500k and a sell on

[faraway saint 22,375]

7 minutes ago, munoz said:

£1.5m for Morgan then . No less .

If Hibs are struggling to get £1m for McGinn there's not a flippin hope we'll get that for Morgan.

Love your optimism........................

[Drew 21,115]

3 hours ago, HSS said:

Notts are County....Forest are Nottingham.

That's me told

I have very little interest in English football, so couldn't really care less, to be blunt.

Thanks for the info, however (I think).

Edited August 29, 2017 by Drew

[munoz 5,326]

7 minutes ago, faraway saint said:

If Hibs are struggling to get £1m for McGinn there's not a flippin hope we'll get that for Morgan.

Love your optimism........................

Tongue was firmly in cheek tbh , but I really see us letting him go on the cheap this time . We don't need to sell , the player is happy to bide his time , so it will take a decent bid I reckon.

[shull 27,738]

2 minutes ago, Drew said:

That's me told

Not even a thanks, just a flippant retort. 

Suppose we beat Dundee last Saturday. 

[munoz 5,326]

17 minutes ago, DougJamie said:

Think that would be a record by a mile for a second tier Scot. We cant command that.............. best we can hope for is 500k and a sell on

Is a realistic amount (500k) for arguably the best player in our division.

[div 12,965]

3 minutes ago, munoz said:

Tongue was firmly in cheek tbh , but I really see us letting him go on the cheap this time . We don't need to sell , the player is happy to bide his time , so it will take a decent bid I reckon.

We don't need to sell but he is in the last year of his contract so there will be a tipping point at which the board have a big decision to make.

To turn down £250K or whatever was a pretty brave move but one to be applauded given that he could genuinely be the difference between promotion and not this season IMO.

If a bid came in for say £400K it might be very difficult to turn down.

Guess it also depends on what the development fee would be if he leaves under freedom of contract.

[munoz 5,326]

16 minutes ago, faraway saint said:

If Hibs are struggling to get £1m for McGinn there's not a flippin hope we'll get that for Morgan.

Love your optimism........................

I'd be very surprised if J McGinn goes for less than £1.5m .

[HSS 10,613]

15 minutes ago, Drew said:

 

Thanks for the info, however (I think).

It'll come in handy one day.

[Drew 21,115]

4 minutes ago, HSS said:

It'll come in handy one day.

Aye, perhaps it will.

To be honest, I genuinely had no idea that there is an etiquette for referring to the respective clubs.

I'm even more clueless about English soccerball than I am about the game up here, and that's going some!

Edited August 29, 2017 by Drew

[HSS 10,613]

Just now, Drew said:

Aye, perhaps it will.

To be honest, I genuinely had no idea that there is an etiquette for referring to the clubs respectively.

I'm even more clueless about English soccerball than I am about the game up here, and that's going some!

Have you ever heard County referred to as Nottingham County?

Forest fans hate their name being abbreviated to Notts.

PS.Why is abbreviated such a big word?

[faraway saint 22,375]

16 minutes ago, munoz said:

I'd be very surprised if J McGinn goes for less than £1.5m .

Who knows what he might go for but at the minute it seems £750,000 has been offered.

All subjective, players are worth what other teams pay for them, not what some fans think.