Maybe Brophy's a Livi supporter  

1 hour ago, truesaint said:

presume the guy was referring to Don thomas and Iain wilson but they didn't play or were even registered as subs for kilmarnock in any of the games. Clarity from clowns above required.

 

The two players concerned both played v Dunfermline in the section. One of them, Euan Deveney ,  played for Falkirk v Rangers I think.

 

Edited January 13, 20215 yr by billyg

39 minutes ago, billyg said:

 

The two were layers concerned both played v Dunfermline in the section. One of them played for Falkirk v Rangers I think.

 

So is Brophy available for Livingstone Billy ? 

7 minutes ago, portmahomack saint said:

So is Brophy available for Livingstone Billy ? 

Ffs calm down, who cares....he wasn't there to get Saints this far so no need to panic...getting yourself in some state!

1 hour ago, billyg said:

 

The two players concerned both played v Dunfermline in the section. One of them, Euan Deveney ,  played for Falkirk v Rangers I think.

 

Ok so neither Falkirk or Kilmarnock made it out of group stages so would be irrelevant to our point with brophy.

Falkirk got through, Sevco thumped them 4 nil.

11 minutes ago, scam75 said:

Falkirk got through, Sevco thumped them 4 nil.

But again Deveny was not in team or or bench for Kilmarnock round 1.

 

7 minutes ago, scam75 said:

Falkirk got through, Sevco thumped them 4 nil.

Indeed Euan Deveney played for Kilmarnock in the 1st round group stages (against Dunfermline), then played for Falkirk in the next round. So he doesn't appear to have been cup tied.

I wonder if that's enough clarity.

8 minutes ago, truesaint said:

But again Deveny was not in team or or bench for Kilmarnock round 1.

FFS! Yes he was. 

Also, Innes Cameron, on the team sheet below, subsequently played for Ayr United in round 2.

Edited January 13, 20215 yr by FTOF

3 minutes ago, FTOF said:

FFS! Yes he was. 

Sure it wasn't justin devenny

https://www.google.com/search?q=kilmarnock+betfred+cup&rlz=1CAEAQE_enGB810&oq=kilmarnock+betfred+cup&aqs=chrome.0.69i59.10668j0j7&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8#sie=m;/g/11kn0pk4b7;2;/m/04dq3c;ln;fp;1;;

                   

 

 

Edited January 13, 20215 yr by pod

Not unless Justin begins with an "E" in some parallel world.

It's a Kilmarnock fan that is giving me this info. I'm sure he'd know the difference between the two.

1 hour ago, God of war said:

Ffs calm down, who cares....he wasn't there to get Saints this far so no need to panic...getting yourself in some state!

That's was a bit of a overreaction Jesus Christ man !  Sorry should have said for God sake God, but it was funny 

4 minutes ago, FTOF said:

Not unless Justin begins with an "E" in some parallel world.

It's a Kilmarnock fan that is giving me this info. I'm sure he'd know the difference between the two.

Are you sure?

It's awright, just taking the piss E was playing and J was on the bench

 

Not good news 

Since he is on loan, can we not send him back to Killie  ?    

7 minutes ago, Tommy said:

Since he is on loan, can we not send him back to Killie  ?    

That's normally the case. Would allow us to look at free agents if he does go back

5 minutes ago, Gosport Buddie said:

That's normally the case. Would allow us to look at free agents if he does go back

Who would pay his wages ?  

2 hours ago, alanb said:

Not good news 

Not bad news either really for us, Brophy and Dennis both injured but we have played most of season without them playing so not much of a loss. Only real loss is McGrath...

If Brophy came to us with a foot fracture surely to goodness he underwent a medical some questions to answer here surely

Not bad news either really for us, Brophy and Dennis both injured but we have played most of season without them playing so not much of a loss. Only real loss is McGrath...

If Brophy came to us with a foot fracture surely to goodness he underwent a medical some questions to answer here surely

Not ever fracture is detectable. [emoji15]

Says the guy that told someone to run off a broken bone in his foot. [emoji23]

1 hour ago, Mid Calder Saint said:

If Brophy came to us with a foot fracture surely to goodness he underwent a medical some questions to answer here surely

Depends on what procedures are carried out during a medical. Also, stress fractures tend not to be painful in their infancy, so Brophy might not even have known he had it, as they can go unnoticed until the fracture reaches a critical point.

Stress fractures are quite difficult spot on an X-Ray. Some of them only really become obvious on an X-Ray when the injury begins to heal.

Diagnosing a Foot Stress Fracture (sports-health.com)

Having said that, with a three year contract and a significant financial outlay, you would expect an MRI to be carried out, which has a better (but not definite) chance of picking it up.

Edited February 12, 20215 yr by FTOF

2 minutes ago, FTOF said:

Depends on what procedures are carried out during a medical. Also, stress fractures tend not to be painful in their infancy, so Brophy might not even have known he had it, as they can go unnoticed until the fracture reaches a critical point.

Stress fractures are quite difficult spot on an X-Ray. Some of them only really become obvious on an X-Ray when the injury begins to heal.

Diagnosing a Foot Stress Fracture (sports-health.com)

Having said that, maybe you would expect an MRI to be carried out, which has a better (but not definite) chance of picking it up.

Thank you Doctor. 

10 minutes ago, faraway saint said:

Thank you Doctor. 

Hardly.

Who do think I am? Walter Mitty. We've already got one of those on here.