Speculation Thread

[FTOF]

8 minutes ago, RossCSmfc said:

Is it just me who thinks Muzek was hopeless? Thought Erhahon outperformed him at LB last season.

He was pretty solid, but he did have a couple of games where he cost us goals, due to being caught out of position.

I'd still have taken him back, but we could get better.

[Sonny]

Is it just me who thinks Muzek was hopeless? Thought Erhahon outperformed him at LB last season.
eta: young Ethan struggled but still was better than an “experienced” Muzek.

Just you.

[faraway saint]

37 minutes ago, cockles1987 said:

It's just you

 

11 minutes ago, Sonny said:

45 minutes ago, RossCSmfc said:

Is it just me who thinks Muzek was hopeless? Thought Erhahon outperformed him at LB last season.
eta: young Ethan struggled but still was better than an “experienced” Muzek.

Just you.

No just you that says that. 

[Ayrshire Saints]

2 hours ago, pod said:

He's French. 

Do your homework, I'm well aware he's French. His current / last contract was in Bulgaria !!!

[billyg]

I was hoping for the Juventus guy who has a great pedigree. Not sure about the French player , when you consider some of the dumplings that got contracts at Dundee a year ago , yet he failed to get a deal. Then only made 7 appearances for Levski . 

[FTOF]

10 minutes ago, billyg said:

I was hoping for the Juventus guy who has a great pedigree. Not sure about the French player , when you consider some of the dumplings that got contracts at Dundee a year ago , yet he failed to get a deal. Then only made 7 appearances for Levski . 

Looking at it from another perspective, maybe McCann couldn't spot a decent player even if he booted him in the nuts.

Anyway, both players were rumours and we might not be or have been in for them anyway.

Edited August 7, 2019 by FTOF

[pod]

44 minutes ago, Ayrshire Saints said:

Do your homework, I'm well aware he's French. His current / last contract was in Bulgaria !!!

Yes teacher.    Wooooosh. 

Edited August 7, 2019 by pod

[kevo_smfc]

13 minutes ago, FTOF said:

Looking at it from another perspective, maybe McCann couldn't spot a decent player even if he booted him in the nuts.

Anyway, both players were rumours and we might not be or have been in for them anyway.

Theres one of the players that played for us vs Stenny as a trials been snapped up by Newcastle. Think he was the big lanky French centre half.

Edited August 7, 2019 by kevo_smfc

[mattman]

7 hours ago, insaintee said:

Sigh. The ones that got away 

Tbf imo (and not cos I know his dad) he’d of been a good squad player for us, we literally have 1 winger at the moment 😂 and he possibly could of got me away comps ☺️😂

[mattman]

6 hours ago, kevo_smfc said:

I am sure someone mentioned we offered him a deal till January and he wasn't happy with that. Signs till January with Falkirk. Could be bollocks and we actually didn't offer him a contract at all. 

We did. 

[faraway saint]

4 minutes ago, mattman said:

Tbf imo (and not cos I know his dad) he’d of been a good squad player for us, we literally have 1 winger at the moment 😂 and he possibly could of got me away comps ☺️😂

That's my boy, I like your style. 

[mattman]

1 minute ago, faraway saint said:

That's my boy, I like your style. 

Damn right! Some right silly prices to get in some of the Scottish grounds🙈

 

on that point we should be charging teams exactly what we get charged when we visit their grounds. Outrageous prices at times, I’m glad I’ve still got a babyface and can pass for an under 12 👀😂😂

[StanleySaint]

Theres one of the players that played for us vs Stenny as a trials been snapped up by Newcastle. Think he was the big lanky French centre half.

He's been signed for their development squad, we need someone ready to hit the ground running

[jaybee]

3 hours ago, cockles1987 said:

4 hours ago, RossCSmfc said:

Is it just me who thinks Muzek was hopeless? Thought Erhahon outperformed him at LB last season.

It's just you

Sorry not just one; I imagine there area couple more who though Muzek Ok, but not exceptional, Popescu was excellent Muzek merely OK

[Sonny]

5 minutes ago, jaybee said:

Sorry not just one; I imagine there area couple more who though Muzek Ok, but not exceptional, Popescu was excellent Muzek merely OK

Aye, But the point being made was Muzek was not OK but that he was hopeless. Big difference.

[jaybee]

5 minutes ago, Sonny said:

14 minutes ago, jaybee said:

Sorry not just one; I imagine there area couple more who though Muzek Ok, but not exceptional, Popescu was excellent Muzek merely OK

Aye, But the point being made was Muzek was not OK but that he was hopeless. Big difference.

Fair play, my point was it was worth pursuing Popescu but NOT Muzek. 

[Sonny]

4 minutes ago, jaybee said:

Fair play, my point was it was worth pursuing Popescu but NOT Muzek. 

I respect your opinion but totally disagree. Muzek has played in the Champions League and Europa league the last few weeks but is not good enough St Mirren? He is far from hopeless and made a significant difference to our defence when he replaced Ethan who had become a liability.

[linwood buddie]

Muzak started off well and tailed off a wee bit at the end of the season , seemed to lose a bit of concentration ,overall I thought he was decent . 

[Hendo]

17 minutes ago, Sonny said:

I respect your opinion but totally disagree. Muzek has played in the Champions League and Europa league the last few weeks but is not good enough St Mirren? He is far from hopeless and made a significant difference to our defence when he replaced Ethan who had become a liability.

Agree with this. Apart from the mistake for the goal away in Perth, I thought he was solid and easily good enough to be a top player in the SPL. 

[Wilbur]

6 minutes ago, Hendo said:

Agree with this. Apart from the mistake for the goal away in Perth, I thought he was solid and easily good enough to be a top player in the SPL. 

....... and missing his penalty vs Dundee Utd in the play off match.

😎

[Hendo]

24 minutes ago, Wilbur said:

....... and missing his penalty vs Dundee Utd in the play off match.

😎

He did that deliberately so Hladky could be the hero and win it for us!

[jaybee]

1 hour ago, Sonny said:

1 hour ago, jaybee said:

Fair play, my point was it was worth pursuing Popescu but NOT Muzek. 

I respect your opinion but totally disagree. Muzek has played in the Champions League and Europa league the last few weeks but is not good enough St Mirren? He is far from hopeless and made a significant difference to our defence when he replaced Ethan who had become a liability.

Well I shan't get into fisticuffs over it, it is all about opinions. let me just say If one could come back and only one, well it wouldn't be Muzek. But your view is just as valid as that of anyone else.  

[Prague Buddie]

1 hour ago, Sonny said:

I respect your opinion but totally disagree. Muzek has played in the Champions League and Europa league the last few weeks but is not good enough St Mirren? He is far from hopeless and made a significant difference to our defence when he replaced Ethan who had become a liability.

Muzek was nothing special.Average to ok at best. We can definitely do better. Hodson was better than him when he played at left back. He was on a par with Erhahon, who is at least young and will improve. 

As for the playing in the Champions league and Europa league QUALIFIERS ,  so have players from The New Saints, Lingfield and Dundalk. 

Edited August 7, 2019 by Prague Buddie

[saintargyll]

Well . . . I would rule out a loan deal for Lewis Morgan . . . Poor tonight

lesson to all the young players at St.Mirren . . Don't leave

stay and learn your trade,the big bucks will come soon enough

[norrie82]

With the greatest respect to Ethan Musek was a far better player. I hope Ethan improves but if he was a 29 year old and not from our academy people wouldn’t be so forgiving.