Cammy MacPherson. Are we aff wur heed?

[FTOF]

According to individuals on The fakes thread on P & B, their collective opinion is that Cammy McPherson is absolutely rotten.

 

[billyg]

3 hours ago, FTOF said:

According to individuals on The fakes thread on P & B, their collective opinion is that Cammy McPherson is absolutely rotten.

 

We can take their opinions with a pinch of salt , they think Shaun Rooney is a superstar ! ☺️

[HSS]

27 minutes ago, billyg said:

We can take their opinions with a pinch of salt , they think Shaun Rooney is a superstar ! ☺️

i  would hope we bring him back but he could do a job for st j in the championship next season 

[truesaint]

Cammy has been recalled back from St Johnstone.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/60097941

[JJ McG]

1 hour ago, truesaint said:

Cammy has been recalled back from St Johnstone.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/60097941

Bizarre move, he’s been absolutely dreadful according to st Johnstone fans and has been as good as a man down.

[magnus]

24 minutes ago, JJ McG said:

Bizarre move, he’s been absolutely dreadful according to st Johnstone fans and has been as good as a man down.

Signed a pre contract with them. Seems we are looking for some cash. All a bit odd.

[billyg]

22 minutes ago, magnus said:

Signed a pre contract with them. Seems we are looking for some cash. All a bit odd.

JG has just confirmed he's signed a PCA with the Fakes , and we've recalled him , crazy situation !

[linwood buddie]

Take it we lose out on any development money for not offering a new contract?

[Slarti]

Take it we lose out on any development money for not offering a new contract?

Didn't we?

[linwood buddie]

16 minutes ago, Slarti said:

28 minutes ago, linwood buddie said:

Take it we lose out on any development money for not offering a new contract?

Didn't we?

Don’t know .

[FTOF]

1 hour ago, billyg said:

JG has just confirmed he's signed a PCA with the Fakes , and we've recalled him , crazy situation !

Not really. As JG says, why help them out in their time of strife without any financial outlay?

Jim Goodwin sets out St Mirren stance on Cammy MacPherson as he tells St Johnstone to cough up if they want midfielder back - Daily Record

I'm not sure whether the "buying" club or the player have to inform us that MacPherson has signed a PCA or not. If it's the latter, then the fakes have fucked it up big time.

They're always going on about how loaded they are. I'd say £100K will be enough to secure one of our prize assets.

 

Edited January 22, 2022 by FTOF

[Slarti]

Don’t know .

Me neither.

[billyg]

44 minutes ago, FTOF said:

Not really. As JG says, why help them out in their time of strife without any financial outlay?

Jim Goodwin sets out St Mirren stance on Cammy MacPherson as he tells St Johnstone to cough up if they want midfielder back - Daily Record

I'm not sure whether the "buying" club or the player have to inform us that MacPherson has signed a PCA or not. If it's the latter, then the fakes have fucked it up big time.

They're always going on about how loaded they are. I'd say £100K will be enough to secure one of our prize assets.

 

When I said crazy , I meant very unusual , I can't remember another example where this happened ?

 

[FTOF]

2 minutes ago, billyg said:

When I said crazy , I meant very unusual , I can't remember another example where this happened ?

I see what you mean.

 

[Cumbriansaint72]

I can see JG's point really. Mc Pherson doesn't feature in his plans, he's out on loan and signed a PCA with club. He has been recalled but will be so far down pecking order he won't play unless the fakes want him now then they need to pay a bit otherwise they will get a non match fit player. Good move by JG imo.

[DumboBud]

The danger is that we now have an unhappy player in the camp that won’t be there next season. Unless this is resolved in the few days I can’t see it being a good thing. 

[Tommy]

42 minutes ago, DumboBud said:

The danger is that we now have an unhappy player in the camp that won’t be there next season. Unless this is resolved in the few days I can’t see it being a good thing. 

He can train with youth players then and be nowhere near the seniors players 

 

[MenstrieSaint]

1 hour ago, DumboBud said:

The danger is that we now have an unhappy player in the camp that won’t be there next season. Unless this is resolved in the few days I can’t see it being a good thing. 

If he has signed a PCA and we offer him a contract  , will it be the case that a fee could be set by a tribunal , so that would mean it makes sense both clubs agree a fee this window . Clever I think . Would still prefer Cammy stays with us 

 

[pod]

2 hours ago, DumboBud said:

 Unless this is resolved in the few days I can’t see it being a good thing. 

It will be, if it weakens more an already weak St.Johnstone side

[Maboza]

All very confusing. Surely Saintees were going to be paying his wages for the remainder of the season. 
 

By calling him back we risk being lumbered with that outlay unless they think it’s worth the cash to spring him early.  
 

Would we be due a development fee from the PCA? 

[Cookie Monster]

All very confusing. Surely Saintees were going to be paying his wages for the remainder of the season. 
 
By calling him back we risk being lumbered with that outlay unless they think it’s worth the cash to spring him early.  
 
Would we be due a development fee from the PCA? 

Were they paying all his wages?

It all depends on what he was earning and what he will be earning. If they are willing to pay more than he was currently on, then we only need to offer what he was currently on to receive a fee if he has already signed a PCA. I think. [emoji848][emoji1787]

[djchapsticks]

Smart move. I imagine Cammy isn't one of our bigger earners so bringing him back for the rest of the season forces St. Johnstone's hand one way or the other and does so at relatively little cost to ourselves. 

Like it or not they are rivals in terms of where 5hey are in the league in comparison to us so if they want to strengthen with one of our assets, then they should be paying the premium to do so. 

[djchapsticks]

Also worth noting that we'll more than likely offer Cammy a new deal on the wages he's currently on, so even if we can't draw a fee for him now, St. Johnstone will still need to pay a development fee for him as he was still under 23 at the start of this season.

[Rascal]

21 hours ago, FTOF said:

Not really. As JG says, why help them out in their time of strife without any financial outlay?

Jim Goodwin sets out St Mirren stance on Cammy MacPherson as he tells St Johnstone to cough up if they want midfielder back - Daily Record

I'm not sure whether the "buying" club or the player have to inform us that MacPherson has signed a PCA or not. If it's the latter, then the fakes have fucked it up big time.

They're always going on about how loaded they are. I'd say £100K will be enough to secure one of our prize assets.

 

Makes sense

[beyond our ken]

On 1/22/2022 at 5:24 PM, JJ McG said:

Bizarre move, he’s been absolutely dreadful according to st Johnstone fans and has been as good as a man down.

Their whole team has been garbage for weeks now, months even.  He could be pish and still be their best player.